The MedSleep decision concerns whether a medical clinic’s fee-sharing arrangements formed part of an exempt supply of patient care or involved separate taxable services to physicians. It does not establish that every clinic overhead charge is exempt from GST/HST.

What the case examined

In MedSleep Inc. v. The King, 2025 TCC 70, the Tax Court considered the agreements and the integrated roles of clinic staff and physicians in delivering sleep-medicine services. On those facts, the court found a single compound exempt supply to patients rather than the separate supply alleged by CRA.

The decision’s importance is the analysis of what was actually supplied, by whom and to whom. It should not be reduced to a rule that a percentage fee is exempt while a fixed fee is taxable.

Why other clinic arrangements can differ

A clinic may separately supply premises, equipment or administrative services to a practitioner. CRA’s published medical-practice guidance discusses taxable supplies in such arrangements. The fact that the practitioner provides exempt medical care does not automatically exempt every input they buy.

Review substance as well as the contract

Changing the word “overhead” to “fee share” does not by itself change the tax result. Compare the signed agreement with the actual work, invoicing, patient relationships, collection of fees and allocation of responsibilities.

  • Who contracts to provide the service to the patient?
  • What does each party supply and to whom?
  • How are professional and technical fees billed and collected?
  • Does the arrangement involve one supply or multiple supplies?

Before changing billing or claiming a refund

Have a GST/HST adviser assess the current law, relevant case history and your specific arrangement. Past payments, objection or rebate deadlines, documentation and input tax credits can all matter. A favourable case for another clinic does not automatically establish your entitlement.

CoPilot Tax partner Mohammed Al-khooly’s commentary on the case appeared in Canadian Healthcare Network’s coverage of MedSleep.