Tax planning for the sale of a Canadian startup should begin before negotiations. The structure of the sale, ownership history and company assets can affect the seller’s tax outcome. There is no standard structure that makes every exit tax-free.

Start with a share sale versus an asset sale

In a share sale, the shareholder sells shares. In an asset sale, the corporation sells business assets and the owner may then need to withdraw the proceeds. The tax consequences differ for both buyer and seller.

The lifetime capital gains exemption (LCGE) may be available to an eligible individual disposing of qualified small business corporation shares. It is not an exemption for an ordinary asset sale by the company.

Review the QSBC share tests early

Qualified small business corporation share status involves the corporation’s assets, ownership and the period before the sale. At disposition, all or substantially all of the relevant asset value generally must meet the qualifying active-business or connected-corporation tests. CRA commonly uses 90% as a guideline for “all or substantially all.”

Separate tests apply through the preceding 24 months, including a more-than-50% qualifying-asset test and ownership conditions. Fair market value matters, not just the balance-sheet carrying amount. Share issues, reorganizations and changes in business assets can affect the analysis.

Check the seller’s available exemption

The LCGE is a limit on qualifying capital gains, not a blanket exemption for sale proceeds. Use the limit and legislation applicable to the sale year. Previous claims, losses and the cumulative net investment loss rules may affect the available deduction. Alternative minimum tax can also affect the immediate cash tax result.

Have the expected gain and the seller’s eligibility calculated before relying on a projected after-tax price. The original guide’s illustration of a $5 million sale with no tax should not be treated as an outcome available to every family.

Family trusts and family ownership

A properly established trust may allocate qualifying gains to eligible beneficiaries, subject to the trust terms and tax rules. The beneficiaries must meet their own requirements and have available deduction capacity. Allocating a gain is a real legal and financial decision; it does not simply let the founder borrow someone else’s exemption.

Review attribution, TOSI, trust reporting, distributions and the 21-year deemed-disposition rule with the advisers. Changing ownership after substantial value has accrued can itself trigger tax. Read more about family trusts and the LCGE.

Purification and holding companies

Purification describes steps to address non-qualifying assets before a share sale. A holding company may form part of the plan, but transfers and intercorporate dividends require their own analysis, including section 55 and Part IV tax.

Moving intellectual property or investments can also affect contracts, creditors, valuation and what a buyer wants to acquire. Complete the tax and legal analysis before moving assets.

Documents to bring to an exit-planning meeting

  • Current and historical ownership records and share terms.
  • Financial statements and an asset list with estimated fair market values.
  • Details of investments, surplus cash, related companies and shareholder loans.
  • Trust deeds, prior capital-gains claims and relevant personal tax balances.
  • The proposed deal structure, price allocation, payment timing and earn-out terms.

Ask for a comparison of realistic sale structures and their costs. A useful plan also identifies which conditions must remain true between now and closing.