This article began as commentary on the CRA’s request for Shopify merchant information reported in 2023. It is retained as a historical item. The ongoing lesson for online sellers is to maintain records that explain sales, refunds, fees and tax reporting across every platform.

What is an unnamed persons requirement?

An unnamed persons requirement is a process through which CRA can seek information from a third party about an identifiable group whose individual members are not all known to the agency. Judicial authorization and statutory conditions apply.

The request itself is not proof that every merchant has failed to comply. Information can be used to compare reported activity with filing, registration and payment obligations.

Distinguish historical requests from current obligations

News about an application does not establish that a court granted it, that a particular seller was audited or that the litigation remains at the same stage. CRA’s published audit manual discusses the Shopify proceedings and the importance of defining a requested group clearly.

Merchants should assess their own records and obligations independently of the outcome of a particular platform-information case.

Reconcile gross sales to bank deposits

Platform payouts can differ from sales because of fees, refunds, chargebacks, reserves and taxes collected. Keep reports that bridge the gross activity to the amount deposited. Combine all stores, payment processors and offline transactions in the accounting records.

Review income tax and sales tax separately

Reporting business profit does not by itself settle GST/HST registration and collection. Check thresholds, taxable supplies and sales locations. Foreign sales can also require analysis under the destination’s rules.

Address errors with the right process

A normal reassessment period is not a universal three-year limit on every CRA inquiry. Exceptions and different rules apply. If past returns are incomplete, reconstruct the figures and consider an adjustment or the current voluntary disclosures rules. Relief is not automatic.

Keep source records and a written explanation of corrections. Platform access can change, so export the information regularly.